ToxicsWatch
Alliance (TWA)
Press Release
ToxicsWatch mourns
death of man who pushed for asbestos registry for public buildings
Russia may ban
asbestos, French leader charged with manslaughter for promoting asbestos
use
Indian Navy against
Russian asbestos, Govts ignore NHRC’s notice seeking response on banning white
asbestos
New Delhi November 9, 2012: Governments continue to pretend
ignorance about the sick buildings having asbestos, the death of Howard
Willems, a building inspector who had asked his Saskatchewan provincial
government in Canada to release a list of public buildings that contain
asbestos underlines the significance of his demand. He died on November 8 from
mesothelioma, a form of cancer that develops from inhaling asbestos fibres. In
India, no building is marked asbestos due to the collusion between Government
agencies and the asbestos companies. ToxicsWatch Alliance (TWA) demands that
all the buildings having asbestos must be marked with asbestos sign and a
Danger Symbol. TWA demands that details about asbestos containment in public
buildings be listed online.
Before his death, Howard Willems said in media
interviews last week that people should know if they’re going into buildings that have
asbestos — especially if there is construction work. In India, asbestos
continues to be used in the buildings all the constructions workers, labour
inspectors and residents under those buildings are under threat of exposure of
asbestos fibers.
In India, National Human Rights Commission (NHRC)’s notices
on gnawing public concerns from lung cancer causing asbestos have been ignored
in general.Howard Willems died after a long battle with mesothelioma, a rare
form of cancer that comes from inhaling asbestos fibres. Willems used to work
as a building inspector for 31 years. Willems had said the buildings he entered
were not marked and there was no warning on the insulating material. He added
he would have taken steps to protect himself had he known there was asbestos in
the buildings he inspected.
Ongoing anti-asbestos struggle in
Bihar and Odisha shows that if the governments do not act to save public health
informed citizens and villagers can act to stop such hazardous factories which
are harmful to the present and future generations. In a related development,
District Magistrate, Vaishali, Bihar has convened a meeting with Khet Bachao
Jeevan Bachao Jansagharsh Committee, Vashali on October 10, 2012 to hear
villagers’ grievance against the proposed asbestos based factory of Utkal
Asbestos Limited.
Revealing growing awareness about hazards from asbestos
fibers, the news report on the delivery of the INS Vikramaditya, a former
Russian naval aircraft carrier (formerly Admiral Gorshkov) dated Sep 17, 2012
published in DefenseWorld.net
stated, “India refused to use asbestos to protect the boilers from heat,
fearing that the material was dangerous for the crew" according to Russian
officials. The statement of the official spokesperson for the Indian Navy,
Commander PVS Satish, read: “There is no question of India’s refusal to use of
asbestos since it’s internationally banned. At the time of signing the
contract, it was simply specified in the agreement.” This merits serious attention
of the Indian ministries of commerce, finance and rural development which have
been promoting its use despite concerns expressed by ministries of environment,
labour, chemicals and health besides Kerala State Human Rights Commission.
It is noteworthy that Russian company is the largest
supplier of asbestos to India unmindful of the fact that almost the entire
developed world has banned its use. It has come to light that on September 7,
2011, the Russian Justice Ministry promulgated a law (standard SanPiN1
2.2.3.2887-11) that recognized the hazard posed by chrysotile asbestos and
chrysotile-containing materials. SanPiN stands for sanitary/epidemiological
rule and standard. SanPiN is a standard issued by the Russian authorities
responsible for the regulation of the manufacture and use of, and exposure to,
chemicals. In the recent past, Russian asbestos companies have frustrated
efforts by the WHO to adopt measures to prevent future asbestos-related diseases
and regulations by UN’s Rotterdam Convention. In June 2011, a technical
regulation drafted by the Russian Federal State Unitary Enterprise proposed a
ban on asbestos in friction materials, enforceable throughout the Eurasian
Economic Community, members of which include Russia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan,
Tajikistan and Belarus. The adoption of standard SanPiN 2.2.3.2887-11 signals
the beginning of the end of Russian asbestos production. ToxicsWatch Alliance
(TWA) hopes that Russian Government will succeed in resisting the harmful
influence of Russian asbestos industry.
It is strange that Russian authorities who are rightly
planning to ban asbestos allowed presence of asbestos in INS Vikramaditya, a
former Russian naval aircraft carrier (formerly Admiral Gorshkov) although
asbestos use is banned by International Maritime Organisation and World Health
Organisation (WHO) and International Labor Organisation (ILO) has called for
elimination of all kinds of asbestos.
Meanwhile, in a significant development, a former French
leader Martine Aubry has been charged with manslaughter and is under
investigation for failing to protect industrial workers from asbestos.
According to the news article published in Expatica, November 7, 2012, “Aubry
was accused of having helped to delay the implementation in France of a 1983
European Union directive designed to strengthen the protection of workers
dealing with asbestos.” Aubry denied the charges and allegations against her,
stating it is a “profound insult to who I am and the professional and political
choices I have made throughout my life.” Martine Aubry, the former leader of
France's governing Socialist Party, has been charged with manslaughter in a
probe into whether state negligence contributed to thousands of deaths caused
by asbestos exposure. The charges against Aubry relate to her time as a senior
official in the ministry of social affairs, a major figure in French politics.
As the ministry's director of industrial relations from 1984-87, Aubry is
accused of having helped to delay the implementation in France of a 1983
European Union directive designed to strengthen the protection of workers
dealing with asbestos.
Aubry bowed to pressure from industrialists lobbying
against a complete ban on the use of the material and that she ignored warnings
from French health authorities of a mushrooming epidemic of cancers and
terminal lung diseases. Aubry, the daughter of former European Commission
President Jacques Delors is caught in a far-reaching probe into how the French
authorities handled the emerging evidence of the dangers posed by asbestos
between 1970 and 1997, when the material was finally banned. The specific
charges against her relate to the case of workers employed at the Fereo-Valeo
auto-components factory in Normandy. Asbestos was once widely used for car
brake pads. An estimated 3,000 people currently die prematurely every year in
France as a result of asbestos poisoning and there have been pessimistic
predictions that the death rate could nearly treble over the next decade
because of exposure in the 70s and 80s. Aubry was formally charged in the early
hours of November 7, 2012.
Signaling the possibility of Indian asbestos manufacturers
facing a similar fate, in a path breaking judgment, an Italian court in Turin
convicted Schmidheiny, a Swiss tycoon and De Cartier, a Belgian baron of
negligence over some 2,200 asbestos-related deaths on February 13, 2012. The
court held that the two had failed to comply with safety rules at building firm
Eternit, where they were key shareholders. Their charges carry a maximum
12-year term. Eternit closed its operations in Italy in 1986 - six years before
asbestos was banned in the country.
It is noteworthy that the
National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) had issued notices on July 6, 2011 on
banning the use of white asbestos, to all states and territories along with
several Union Ministries and asked them to file a status report on it within
four weeks. The NHRC's action came as it
took cognisance of a complaint by TWA alleging that around 50,000 people die
every year in the country due to asbestos related cancer. Only the States of
Mizoram, Nagaland and the National Institute of Occupational Health Ahmedabad
have submitted the reports. The NHRC issued reminders on 21st May, 2012,
returnable in six weeks, to the Chief Secretaries of all States/Union
Territories and other concerned authorities at Centre who have failed to submit
requisite reports so far.
NHRC's intervention has been sought for a ban on the use of
Chrysotile Asbestos known as white asbestos, which is hazardous for the health
and causes various incurable diseases. In the complaint, contradictory position
of the government has been cited on the issue and alleged that though mining of
asbestos has been technically banned by the government, the government allows
its import and that too from the countries which do not prefer its domestic
use. TWA, the complainant has also
requested for grant of a compensation package for present and future victims of
asbestos related diseases.
The NHRC has issued notices to secretaries of Ministries of
Chemical Fertilizers, Environment and Forest, Health and Family Welfare,
Industry and Commerce, Labour and Chief Secretaries of all the States and Union
Territories. The white asbestos is a fibrous material used for building roofs
and walls. White asbestos is considered a hazardous chemical substance for
human lung and over 55 countries in the world have banned its use. However, it
is being used in a number of industries like construction in India, affecting
the workers, their families, communities in the vicinity of the asbestos based
factories and consumers.
For Details: Gopal Krishna, Convener, ToxicsWatch
Alliance (TWA), Mb: 9818089660, E-mail: krishna1715@gmail.com, Web:
toxicswatch.blogspot.com