Make India Asbestos Free

Make India Asbestos Free
For Asbestos Free India

Journal of Ban Asbestos Network of India(BANI) and India Asbestos Victims Association(IAVA). Asbestos Free India campaign of BANI is inspired by trade union movement and right to health campaign. BANI has been working since 2000. It works with peoples movements, doctors, researcher-activists besides trade unions, human rights, environmental, consumer and public health groups. BANI-IAVA demand criminal liability for companies and medico-legal remedy for victims. Editor: Dr. G. Krishna, Advocate

Friday, December 17, 2010

Stop Asbestos Plant in Muzaffarpur

To 

Justice S N Jha
Chairperson 
Bihar Human Rights Commission 
Patna   

Subject-Stop Asbestos Plant in Muzaffarpur 

Sir, 


With reference to my earlier letter November 6, 2010, this is to draw your urgent attention towards the proposed asbestos cement roofing sheet factory in Chainpur, Muzaffarpur. As you are aware the exposure to killer fibers of  constitute human rights violation of the exposed communities, there is an immediate need to protect the villagers from incurable lung cancer and other diseases. Please find attached the pamphlets of the villagers who are bitterly opposed to the asbestos plant that poses a grave threat to their health. 

This factory is coming up unmindful of the fact that some 52 countries have banned asbestos. WHO and ILO too have called for its elimination.

I wish to seek your urgent intervention in the matter of a serious unprecedented environmental and occupational health crisis with regard to unnoticed asbestos epidemic in Muzaffarpur. Even if one asbestos fibre reaches the right place, it causes irreversible damage - leading to asbestosis, lung cancer or mesothelioma. Thirty deaths are caused per day from asbestos-related diseases as per estimates based on US and European studies.

When the world is preparing and planning to get rid of all forms of asbestos, it makes us look stupid in India to be still importing it, we should devote our scarce resources to prevent the impending disaster by phasing it out as soon as we can. Safer substitute materials for white asbestos are available, they should be considered for use.

I am an environmental health researcher. I have worked with national and international organizations working on environmental and occupational health and am an applicant in the Supreme Court in the hazardous wastes/shipbreaking case.

It is high time BHRC took note of the exposures to the residents, consumers and workers from the Asbestos Plant in Muzaffarpur and took immediate remedial measures. The exposure of construction residents, workers and automobile mechanics for instance defies regulatory control efforts in any country.


I wish to draw your urgent attention to the order of Kerala Human Rights Commission (KHRC) that has ruled that exposing Indians to asbestos is a human rights violation. This paves the way for the eventual complete ban on asbestos and its products. On January 31, 2009, the KHRC ruled that the government should take steps to phase out asbestos roofing from all schools in the state.

As per the survey of U.P. Asbestos Limited, Mohanlalganj,Lucknow and Allied Nippon Pvt Ltd, Gaziabad, (U.P), the lung function impairment was found to be higher in subjects exposed for more than 11 years. This was the result of a Central Pollution Control Board sponsored project entitled "Human risk assessment studies in asbestos industries in India". This has been reported in the (2001-2002) Annual Report of Industrial Toxicological Research Centre, Lucknow. It has also been published in the 139th Report of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Environment, Forests, Science and Technology and presented to the parliament on 17th March, 2005.

Given the ubiquitous presence of the fiber, there is no alternative to getting it banned in right earnest. Scientists, doctors, public health researchers, trade unions, activists and civil society groups has been working to persuade the Governments to give up its consistent and continued pro-asbestos industry bias and lack of concern for the asbestos-injured who die one of the most painful deaths imaginable.

Although the Supreme Court of India has ruled that the Government of India must comply with ILO resolutions, so far the ILO resolution (June 14, 2006) stating "the elimination of the future use of asbestos and the identification and proper management of asbestos currently in place are the most effective means to protect workers from asbestos exposures and to prevent future asbestos-related disease and deaths" has not been acted upon.

We earnestly request you to direct all the workers and consumers in your state to take immediate steps to ensure that there no more exposures take place from now on.

Earlier on August 18,2003, the Union Minister of Health and Family Welfare and Parliamentary Affairs informed the Parliament that: "Studies by the National Institute of Occupational Health (NIOH), Ahmedabad, have shown that long-term exposure to any type of asbestos can lead to development of asbestosis, lung cancer and mesothelioma." This was not the first official acknowledgment of the asbestos hazard. Government of India's Office Memorandum NO.6 (6)/94 - Cement, (Sept 1, 1994) of the Ministry of Industry states: "The Department has generally not been recommending any case of Industrial License to any new unit for the creation of fresh capacity of asbestos products in the recent past due to the apprehension that prolonged exposure to asbestos leads to serious health hazards".

Public health researchers, civil society groups, trade unions and human rights groups have demanded an immediate ban on all uses of asbestos including an immediate end to the import of chrysotile. They seek measures to identify, compensate and treat the asbestos-injured and regulations to minimize harmful exposures are also being proposed. They demand criminal prosecution of those responsible for asbestos exposures such as factory owners and company directors. 


Although non-asbestos technology certainly exists in India, in fact in some factories the two technologies exist side-by-side, consumers will inevitably opt for the cheaper product: more demand will translate into higher sales which will generate more chrysotile rupees that can be used to obtain an eve\of political support. As the quid-pro-quo relationship between Government officials and asbestos businessmen exists outside the media spotlight, journalists and the public remain unaware of the pernicious reasons which motivate the decisions being taken; decisions which will expose current and future generations to the deadly asbestos hazard.

The pattern of asbestos disease in Bihar is all set to follow the diseases pattern seen in the developed countries.

Concerned with the global and national evidence about the increasing death toll of asbestos workers, trade unions, labour and environmental groups have sought immediate phase out of chrysotile asbestos. In India asbestos is still used in the manufacture of  pressure and non-pressure pipes used for water supply, sewage, and drainage, packing material, brake linings and jointing used in automobiles, heavy equipment, nuclear power plants, thermal power plants amongst others.

Despite the fact that the World Trade Organisation has given an appropriate judgment against it, upholding France's decision to ban import of asbestos from Canada, successive governments in India have promoted this killer mineral fibre ignoring public health. 

Dr S R Kamat, a renowned lung specialist was bitter at the "utter callousness of employers", the total lack of medical expertise and government inaction; all of which continued to put workers at risk of contracting asbestos related diseases. In the 5 surveys done in the country, large number of the subjects showed asbestos lung diseases. All of them showed breathing problem, many had cough, some had sputum, chest pain finger clubbing and chest pain. Disability in such cases are permanent, progressive; means of compensation are meager, informs Dr Kamat.

White asbestos continues to be in use in India although other kinds such as blue and brown asbestos are banned. Asbestos is being promoted freely in our country whereas the developed countries are keeping away from it.

Taking note of the fact that public concern, regulations and liabilities involved have ended the use of asbestos from the developed countries, delegates at a Round Table wondered, "why is it that the concern of the countries, which have banned asbestos not relevant to India?." Exposing workers to asbestos must be equated to murder and legal provisions must deal with it accordingly. How many consumers would want to use the material if they know that even a single exposure can cause cancer? "Experimental as well as epidemiological studies proved asbestos as carcinogen as well as co-carcinogen. Risk assessment and control of occupational exposure are very poor in developing countries like India," said Dr Qamar Rehman, a renowned toxicologist. There are no industrial physicians and virtually no occupational health centres, whatever the rules may say.

Even World Bank has a policy against asbestos since 1991. "The Bank increasingly prefers to avoid financing asbestos use...Thus, at any mention of asbestos in Bank-assisted projects, the Task Manager needs to exercise special care." Diagnosable asbestosis among workers in most asbestos cement factories and consumer products with no warning labels and unions with no programmes to prevent asbestos disease and exposure in builders and mechanics is alarming.

Delay in stopping asbestos trade and use is a victory for those who do not wish to put health and the environment ahead of commercial interests.

In the light of these findings and developments, in short I seek your immediate intervention to stop the construction of asbestos cement plants in Muzaffarpur in particular and in Bihar in general. I submit that BHRC must consider putting an end to the use of the of all kinds of asbestos products that is being used and encountered daily, because none of the schools, offices, legislatures, courts, hospitals, automobiles, private and public buildings in our state are asbestos free.

Therefore, it is necessary to initiate preventive action in order to protect present and future generations from the silent killer which is akin to a time bomb. I will be glad to share more relevant information against asbestos of all forms including white asbestos (chrysotile) as well. 

Thanking you in anticipation.                   

Yours faithfully

Gopal Krishna
Ban Asbestos Network of India (BANI)


Thursday, December 16, 2010

Lancet Condemns Hypocritical Canada and Quebec

Note:Ban Asbestos Network of India (BANI) expresses its appreciation for The Lancet's World Report on Asbestos titled "Canada accused of hypocrisy over asbestos exports" published on December 9, 2010. The report authored by Tony Kirby notes, "Although Canada will not expose its own citizens to asbestos, its plans to continue exporting the deadly substance to developing countries has drawn widespread condemnation. 

Excerpts from the report:
"Canada’s exports seemed to be at an end. That was until an Indian consortium, led by Montreal-based financier Baljit Chadha, put in a bid to convert the recently closed Jeffrey Mine from an open pit to an underground operation. This would see production and exports run for another 25 years, boosting yearly output to a maximum of 260000 tonnes—around 10% of global production. It would also secure 500 jobs for miners and others. The Quebec Government, led by Jean Charest, is considering providing a $US57 million loan guarantee to the project. A spokesperson for the Quebec Government confirmed the matter was under consideration, and that the government required an economic partner to go ahead. She added that there must be a guarantee both of profitability and that the operators will “follow the rules of safe use of chrysotile effective in Canada."

“‘...If this mine re-opens, the Canadian and Québec Governments will have blood on their hands for generations to come’.” 

BANI has appealed to legislators of Quebec, Canada and India to stop mining of the killer fibers of asbestos. 
Gopal Krishna
Ban Asbestos Network of India (BANI) 

Lancet Condemns Hypocritical Canada and Quebec Governments for Exporting Deadly Asbestos to Vulnerable Developing Countries

Dr Richard Horton, Editor of The Lancet, said: "The links between asbestos and lung cancer, including mesothelioma, have long been established. The governments of Québec and Canada should not be exporting asbestos to developing nations where there are few or no workplace regulations to protect workers or the general population from its lethal effects. They should, as governments of a high-income nation, be setting an example to other asbestos-exporting nations - such as Russia and Kazakhstan - by declaring this practice is no longer acceptable.

"The Lancet adds its voice to those of the many anti-asbestos campaigners worldwide, the Canadian Medical Association (CMA), and others, who are calling for an end to this immoral export of asbestos-related death and disease to some of the most vulnerable people in the world. We call on the Government of Québec not to back re-development of the Jeffrey Mine which would continue asbestos exports for another 25 years. Like WHO, The Lancet will be happy to seeasbestos phased out of use of in all parts of the world." 

If governments in Canada recognise that restrictions and regulations are essential to protect our citizens from the devastating effects of this hazardous product, why do they allow asbestos to be exported to other countries that may lack the resources to protect their own citizens?" asks CMA president Jeff Turnbull. "We have a social responsibility to protect not only the health of Canadians but that of citizens elsewhere who are being harmed by a Canadian export. Canada should not be abdicating this responsibility," he adds. 

For many years, Canada has been a major exporter of white asbestos or 'chrysotile', with other major exporters being Russia, Kazakhstan, and Brazil. But in the past two decades, bans on chrysotile (in addition to those long in force for blue and brown asbestos) have existed, either in law or de facto, in many high-income countries, including the United Kingdom, which banned chrysotile in 1999, and Canada itself, which has not legally banned chrysotile but has a de facto ban. As such, more and more of Canada's asbestos has been going to developing countries, where few or no protections exist and as such a time-bomb of deadly asbestos-related death and disease will continue to grow. Mesothelioma is a specific lung cancer caused by exposure to asbestos, and diagnosis is almost always a death sentence. In the UK, deaths from mesothelioma have climbed from 895 in 1990 to 2,249 in 2008, with no sign of declining, as the effects of workers' exposure in the 1960s and 70s continue to manifest. Similar trends are occurring in other high-income nations. 

Canada's chrysotile resources have been dwindling. However, an Indian-led consortium (led by Montreal-based financier Baljit Chadha) is now planning to convert the recently closed Jeffrey Mine in Québec from open pit to underground, which would see Canada produce and export some 10% of the world's asbestos again. Protests are going on in London (9 Dec), Québec, and Asian cities against the Québec and Canada governments to stop the loan guarantee being given. In London, a coalition of UK anti-
asbestos groups are protesting against the reopening of the Jeffrey Mine outside Canada House, London, before handing in a petition to 10 Downing Street. In Québec, an Asian Delegation from affected importing countries (including Indonesia, India, Korea and Japan) is holding a number of public events and press conferences across the province. 

For full World Report see: http://press.thelancet.com/wrcanada.pdf 

Help ban Canadian asbestos


PLEASE NOTE. If you are outside Canada, then when you send the email, use the David Suzuki Foundation's province & postal code.
 
For province, put Ontario.
 
For postal code, put 
K1P 5H3
Then your message will get sent.
 
 
 
THANK YOU FOR SPEAKING UP TO STOP MORE ASBESTOS DEATHS!

The David Suzuki Foundation, one of Canada's leading environmental groups, has launched a campaign to get 3,000 emails sent to Prime Minister Harper and Premier Charest to stop the financing of the Jeffrey mine.
 
Please forward this email as widely as you can and ask people to click and send a message. Let's get 10,000 emails sent! It takes a couple of seconds to send the message and help stop the plan to finance the export of 5 million tonnes of asbestos to developing countries by Canada for the next quarter century.
 
Please note that people overseas can send the email. You just choose "none" for the question "province". Please note also that you have to answer a simple math question at the end in order to prevent spam.
 
 

Help ban Canadian asbestos

The Canadian chrysotile asbestos industry works hard to promote chrysotile as a safer asbestos, but the International Agency for Research on Cancer and theWorld Health Organization (PDF) remind us that all types of asbestos are cancer-causing and harmful when inhaled. 

At present, the owner of Jeffrey Mine, one of two remaining chrysotile mining operations in Canada, is asking the Quebec Government for a loan guarantee of $58 million to allow the company to extract 200,000 tonnes of asbestos a year. 

Tell Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Quebec Premier Jean Charest to stop propping up the asbestos industry and prevent disease.

Christian Paradis supports killer asbestos industry

Note: 
Staff of the Minister of Natural Resources Canada, Christian Paradis, who represents the Thetford Mines area and is one of the most aggressive fighters for the asbestos industry, 
were involved in illegally removing information that was supposed to have been provided under Access to Information law regarding the Health Canada panel on chrysotile asbestos. 

Kathleen
Two Tory staffers tried to block access to info: CP

Minister of Natural Resources Christian Paradis rises during Question Period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Tuesday, Nov. 2, 2010. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)Minister of Natural Resources Christian Paradis rises during Question Period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Tuesday, Nov. 2, 2010. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)
Updated: Wed Dec. 15 2010

The Canadian Press



OTTAWA — Two more Conservative staffers in the office of cabinet minister Christian Paradis tried to block the release of access-to-information documents, The Canadian Press has learned.


In October, Paradis adviser Sebastien Togneri resigned after it was revealed he had meddled in at least three different access-to-information requests while with the Public Works Department.


Those incidents are the subject of an investigation by the information commissioner.
But two more policy advisers within Paradis' office were also involved in dealing with records destined for public release under access-to-information legislation.


Documents obtained by The Canadian Press show that Marc Toupin and Jillian Andrews both argued against the release of material on sensitive subjects.


In one case dealing with the members of a federal panel who wrote a damning report on asbestos, Paradis' political office had highlighted material it did not want released.


When bureaucrats asked for an explanation, Togneri directed them to his colleague Toupin.


"Those comments are inappropriate and improper, not relevant to the request and should not be disclosed," Toupin said of the material in a July 2009 email.


The manager of access to information and privacy balked at the direction.


"Please note that the Access to Information Act was created to provide access to records under the control of federal institutions and limit the application of severances," Julie Lafrance wrote to Toupin.


"Therefore, the legislators did not include a section in the Act for 'inappropriate and improper' comments."
Andrews intervened in a separate access-to-information request, about preparations for U.S. President Barack Obama's visit to Canada in February 2009. Togneri had argued with bureaucrats that only a single document should be released, and then directed them to Andrews for further "in-depth" analysis.


"Our department specifically states that the only documentation they have pertaining to this is a work stop order," Andrews wrote in July 2009. "The document is found at the very last page of the ATIP. Therefore, this should be the only part of the ATIP to be released."


But another bureaucrat noted in response that officials specifically mandated with collecting documents within the department had put together a much heftier package than a single work-stop order.


It is not clear in either the asbestos or the Obama case whether the documents were ultimately released to the requester. The Canadian Press only asked for correspondence on the processing of four access-to-information files in 2009.


Paradis, now natural resources minister, was asked in October about other staff in his office who might have intervened in access requests, but did not directly answer the question.
A spokesman emphasized Wednesday that Paradis had already accepted the resignation of the person in charge of access to information at the time -- Sebastien Togneri.


"The minister then forwarded the file to the information commissioner and is looking forward to her recommendations," said Richard Walker, Paradis' director of communications.
Prime Minister Stephen Harper's chief of staff, Guy Giorno, issued a memo to all political staff in February, reminding them of the content of the Access to Information Act.


"No political staff member has received a delegation of authority under the Act and therefore no political staff member has authority to make access-to-information decisions," Giorno wrote.


The office of the information commissioner is currently investigating the cases involving Togneri. The former staffer had ordered bureaucrats to retrieve a package of documents from the Public Works mailroom in the summer of 2009 that were destined for The Canadian Press.


He told a Commons committee the following spring that it was a "mistake" and it was the only time he had taken such action, but other incidents were later revealed in more documents.


Togneri and Andrews were asked to appear at the committee at a later date, but the Conservatives announced in May that ministers would take full responsibility for the actions of their staffs and appear on their behalf.



BANI Seeks World Opinion Against Quebec Government

Press Release

BANI Seeks World Opinion Against Quebec Government

TO STOP ASBESTOS MINING IN QUEBEC

New Delhi 16/12/2010: Quebec government, Canada is all set to decide whether to give $58 million financing to an anonymous consortium of foreign investors to open the Jeffrey mine to export 5 million tonnes of asbestos to India and other Asian countries over the next quarter century. India is one of the biggest consumers of asbestos mined in Quebec, a province of Canada although there is ban on asbestos mining in India. In India, Human Rights Commission has ruled that exposing human beings to asbestos fibers is an act human rights violation.

Quebec Premier, Jean Charest must be made to listen to public health experts of the world and his own medical experts and not finance a new generation of asbestos disease in India and other Asian countries. This brings unprecedented dishonor on Quebec in particular and Canada in general.

Ban Asbestos Network of India (BANI) appeals to the world civil society, global academia and world media to act in right earnest to persuade Quebec government to desist from promoting and financing mining and trade in killer fibers of asbestos that has been banned in 52 countries. What is poisonous in these countries cannot be inhumanly presented as non-poisonous in India and other Asian countries. Promoting mining and trade in lung cancer causing fibers of Quebec asbestos constitutes an act of barbarism.

BANI makes a solemn appeal to the legislators of the world to use their persuasive power to stop Quebec Premier Charest from doing the indefensible act of financing an anonymous consortium of foreign investors to open the Jeffrey asbestos mine. This will lead to an unprecedented epidemic of preventable but incurable asbestos related diseases due to export of 5 million tonnes of asbestos to India and other Asian countries in the coming years.

BANI urges Indian legislators to ensure immediate ban on asbestos trade from Canada and other countries in supreme public interest to protect present and future generation of Indians. Indian government must abandon its negotiations for a free trade agreement with Canada unless Quebec stops its naked pursuit for blind profit at the cost of asbestos victims. BANI has written letters to the Speaker of Canadian House of Commons, Yvon Vallières, President of the National Assembly of Québec and the heads of both the houses of Indian Parliament in this regard. The letter is available on BANI's blog. Vallières is also President of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Francophonie (APF).

For Details: Gopal Krishna, Ban Asbestos Network of India (BANI), Mb:07739308480, 09818089660, E-mail: krishna2777@gmail.com, Web: banasbestosindia.blogspot.com

To

Mr Yvon Vallières,
President
National Assembly of Québec
Québec City

Subject-BANI Appeal to National Assembly of Québec on Asbestos Mining

Sir,

With due respect this is with reference to Quebec government's role in giving $58 million financing to an anonymous consortium of foreign investors to open the Jeffrey mine to export 5 million tonnes of asbestos to India and other Asian countries over the next quarter century. India is one of the biggest consumers of asbestos mined in Quebec, a province of Canada although there is ban on asbestos mining in India. In India, Human Rights Commission has ruled that exposing human beings to asbestos fibers is an act human rights violation.

On behalf of Indian citizens, I wish to request you to persuade Quebec Premier, Jean Charest to listen to public health experts of the world and his own medical experts and not to finance a new generation of asbestos disease in India and other Asian countries. This brings unprecedented dishonor on Quebec in particular and Canada in general.

I wish to submit that the silence of National Assembly of Quebec in the matter of human rights violations due to exposure from Quebec asbestos is deafening.The time is now for the Quebec legislature to legislate a law that puts public health before blind lust for profit of the asbestos industry.

In the aftermath of the 26th Anniversary of World’s worst industrial disaster caused by Union Carbide Corporation (UCC), a US company, I submit that in the US, Dow Chemicals Company has set aside $2.2 billion to address future asbestos-related liabilities arising out of the UCC’s acquisition. There no such initiative by the Quebec and Indian asbestos companies although it is an established fact that asbestos is a known human carcinogen that claims more than 100,000 lives every year.

The World Health Organization (WHO), the International Labour Organization (ILO) and the International Trade Union Confederation (ITUC), representing 176 million workers in 151 countries have all called for an end to the use of any form of asbestos, including chrysotile asbestos, which represents 100% of the global asbestos trade.

Amidst a growing demand for a global ban on all kinds of asbestos and its products, Ban Asbestos Network of India (BANI), an alliance of occupational and environmental groups and public health researchers’ appeal to the Committee to recommend that ban on asbestos trade with Canada must be deemed a pre-condition for future negotiations on Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA). On November 16, 2010, Canadian Minister of International Trade Peter Van Loan opened formal talks with our Union Commerce Minister, Anand Sharma on a strategic economic partnership between the two countries.

I submit that BANI which is working to make India asbestos free feels that Canada lost its place as a non-Permanent Member in the UN Security Council because it is fast losing its reputation as a civilized nation because of its position on asbestos trade among other reasons.

BANI is attempting to respond to the public health crisis in India due to trade in asbestos. There is an epidemic of incurable asbestos related diseases and India does not have the environmental and occupational health infrastructure to even diagnose the asbestos diseases.

While Canadian House of Commons is being decontaminated of asbestos, there is not a single building in India including the Indian Parliament which is asbestos free.

I wish to draw your attention towards the fact that a helicopter carrying the President of India hit an asbestos shed at the Bhubaneshwar airport, Orissa (a province in India) on December 9, 2009. The fact is that such asbestos sheds pose a health, environmental and occupational risk to everybody.

In 2006 alone there were more than 1,000 mesothelioma deaths (asbestos related fatal disease) in Japan which along with some 52 countries has banned asbestos. Some 10, 000 people are dying of asbestos related diseases in the US. Indians face and await a similar fate.

I wish to inform you that The White Asbestos (Ban on Use and Import) Bill, 2009 is pending the Rajya Sabha (the Upper House of the Indian Parliament). The issue of health hazards from asbestos has been raised consistently in the Indian Parliament.

The Statement of Objects and Reasons of the White Asbestos (Ban on Use and Import) Bill, 2009 introduced on 31 July 2009 captures clearly the global stand on this issue:

“The white asbestos is highly carcinogenic even the World Health Organisation has reported that it causes cancer. It is a rare fibrous material that is used to make rooftops and brake linings. More than fifty countries have already banned the use and import of white asbestos. Even the countries that export it to India prefer not to use it domestically. But in our country, it is imported without any restriction. Canada and Russia are the biggest exporters of white asbestos. In 2007, Canada exported almost Ninety five percent of the white asbestos it mined and out of it forty-three percent was shipped to India. It is quite surprising that our country is openly importing huge quantity of a product, which causes cancer. This is despite the fact that safer and almost cheap alternatives to asbestos are available in the country. Instead of importing a hazardous material, it will be better if we spend some money in research and development and use environment friendly product. In view of the above, there is an urgent need for a total ban on the import and use of white asbestos and promote the use of alternative material.”
Through you I wish to urge Quebec government and Quebec National Assembly to desist from providing fiscal support to an industry in Quebec which is liable for the fatal asbestos diseases and death of millions of workers and consumers.

In such a context, through you BANI urges the legislators to ensure that ‘ban on asbestos commerce’ must be made a pre-condition for the proposed free trade agreement between India and Canada.

I humbly submit that this provides an unprecedented opportunity to the Canadian Parliament to assert its legislative will and stop the group of international investors who want to purchase the Jeffrey asbestos mine that will lead to production of killer fibers of asbestos to expand from 15,000 to 180, 000 tonne/year in 2012 and eventually to 225,000 tonnes.

Sadly, while the production of asbestos fibers will increase, the reputation of Quebec, Canada as a civilized nation will nose dive to its nadir. Quebec and Canadian government is bigger than the Quebec asbestos industry, the way the members of Quebec National Assembly which you chair acts or does not act will determine the same. It is heartening to know that you are also President of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Francophonie (APF). Therefore, you command a moral authority which will help you comprehend and act to set a precedent in the interest of asbestos victims of the world in general and Indian victims in particular.

I will be glad to share more information about the asbestos victims and related issues.

Thanking You

Warm Regards
Gopal Krishna
Ban Asbestos Network of India (BANI)
New Delhi
Mb: 9818089660
E-mail: krishna2777@gmail.com
Blog: banasbestosindia.blogspot.com

Cc
Mr Jean Charest , Premier, Quebec, Canada
Mr Peter Milliken, Speaker, House of Commons, Canada
Mr Hamid Ansari, Chairman, Rajya Sabha, Upper House of Indian Parliament
Mrs Meira Kumar, Speaker, Lok Sabha, Lower House Indian Parliament

Wednesday, December 8, 2010

BANI Appeal to Canadian Parliament for Ban on Asbestos Trade



To

Mr Peter Milliken, M.P.
Speaker
House of Commons
Speaker's office
Parliament Buildings
Ottawa, Canada

Subject-BANI Appeal to Canadian Parliament for Ban on Asbestos Trade

Sir,

With reference to the scientifically recognized need to make the world asbestos free at the earliest, I wish to submit that the silence of Canadian House of Commons in the matter of human rights violations due to exposure from Canadian asbestos is deafening. The time is now for the Canadian Parliament to legislate a law that puts public health before blind lust for profit of the asbestos industry.

In the aftermath of the 26th Anniversary of World’s worst industrial disaster caused by Union Carbide Corporation (UCC), a US company, I submit that in the US, Dow Chemicals Company has set aside $2.2 billion to address future asbestos-related liabilities arising out of the UCC’s acquisition. There no such initiative by the Canadian and Indian asbestos companies although it is an established fact that asbestos is a known human carcinogen that claims more than 100,000 lives every year.  

The World Health Organization (WHO), the International Labour Organization (ILO) and the International Trade Union Confederation (ITUC), representing 176 million workers in 151 countries have all called for an end to the use of any form of asbestos, including chrysotile asbestos, which represents 100% of the global asbestos trade.

Amidst a growing demand for a global ban on all kinds of asbestos and its products, Ban Asbestos Network of India (BANI), an alliance of occupational and environmental groups and public health researchers’ appeal to the Committee to recommend that ban on asbestos trade with Canada must be deemed a pre-condition for future negotiations on Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA). On November 16, 2010, Canadian Minister of International Trade Peter Van Loan opened formal talks with our Union Commerce Minister, Anand Sharma on a strategic economic partnership between the two countries.

I submit that BANI which is working to make India asbestos free feels that Canada lost its place as a non-Permanent Member in the UN Security Council because it is fast losing its reputation as a civilized nation because of its position on asbestos trade among other reasons.

BANI is attempting to respond to the public health crisis in India due to trade in asbestos. There is an epidemic of incurable asbestos related diseases and India does not have the environmental and occupational health infrastructure to even diagnose the asbestos diseases.

While Canadian House of Commons is being decontaminated of asbestos, there is not a single building in India including the Indian Parliament which is asbestos free.

I wish to draw your attention towards the fact that a helicopter carrying the President of India hit an asbestos shed at the Bhubaneshwar airport, Orissa (a province in India) on December 9, 2009. The fact is that such asbestos sheds pose a health, environmental and occupational risk to everybody. 

In 2006 alone there were more than 1,000 mesothelioma deaths (asbestos related fatal disease) in Japan which along with some 52 countries has banned asbestos. Some 10, 000 people are dying of asbestos related diseases in the US. Indians face and await a similar fate.

I wish to inform you that The White Asbestos (Ban on Use and Import) Bill, 2009 is pending the Rajya Sabha (the Upper House of the Indian Parliament). The issue of health hazards from asbestos has been raised consistently in the Indian Parliament. 

The Statement of Objects and Reasons of the White Asbestos (Ban on Use and Import) Bill, 2009 introduced on 31 July 2009 captures clearly the global stand on this issue:

“The white asbestos is highly carcinogenic even the World Health Organisation has reported that it causes cancer. It is a rare fibrous material that is used to make rooftops and brake linings. More than fifty countries have already banned the use and import of white asbestos. Even the countries that export it to India prefer not to use it domestically. But in our country, it is imported without any restriction. Canada and Russia are the biggest exporters of white asbestos. In 2007, Canada exported almost Ninety five percent of the white asbestos it mined and out of it forty-three percent was shipped to India. It is quite surprising that our country is openly importing huge quantity of a product, which causes cancer. This is despite the fact that safer and almost cheap alternatives to asbestos are available in the country. Instead of importing a hazardous material, it will be better if we spend some money in research and development and use environment friendly product. In view of the above, there is an urgent need for a total ban on the import and use of white asbestos and promote the use of alternative material.”

Through you I wish to Canadian and Quebec government to desist from providing fiscal support to an industry in Quebec which is liable for the fatal asbestos diseases and death of millions of workers and consumers.  

In such a context, through you BANI urges the legislators to ensure that ‘ban on asbestos commerce’ must be made a pre-condition for the proposed free trade agreement between India and Canada.  

I humbly submit that this provides an unprecedented opportunity to the Canadian Parliament to assert its legislative will and stop the group of international investors who want to purchase the Jeffrey asbestos mine that will lead to production of killer fibers of asbestos to expand from 15,000 to 180, 000 tonne/year in 2012 and eventually to 225,000 tonnes.

Sadly, while the production of asbestos fibers will increase, the reputation of Canada as a civilized nation will nose dive to its nadir. Canada as nation is bigger than Canadian and Quebec asbestos industry, the way the members of this august house which you chair acts or does not act will determine the same.     

I will be glad to share more information about the asbestos victims and related issues.

Thanking You

Warm Regards
Gopal Krishna
Ban Asbestos Network of India (BANI) 
New Delhi
Mb: 9818089660
Blog: banasbestosindia.blogspot.com

Cc
Mr Hamid Ansari, Chairman, Rajya Sabha, Upper House of Indian Parliament  
Mrs Meira Kumar, Speaker, Lok Sabha, Lower House Indian Parliament  


Blog Archive